This is a critique, written by jim hoffman, of the march 2005 popular mechanics feature article debunking 911 lies. Debunking the myths in the march 2005 issue of popular mechanics and is written by david dunbar and brad reagan, responding to various 911 conspiracy theories. Mar 17, 2005 a brutal purge of the senior staff at popular mechanics preceded the publication of last months scandalous propaganda piece about 911. By march 2005, the 911 conspiracies were prevalent enough that popular mechanics devoted a special issue to debunking thema project that grew into a book with a foreword by sen. For the editor of this book the events of 911 required involvement of the us government at the highest level. Popular mechanics used a 911 truth website to debunk. Conspiracy theories cant stand up to the hard facts. Prominent scholar on 911, david ray griffin, debunks popular mechanics debunking the 911 myths. Whether its practical diy homeimprovement tips, gadgets and digital technology, information on the newest cars or the latest breakthroughs in science pm is the ultimate guide to our hightech lifestyle. Popular mechanics 2006 book debunking 911 myths did not mention at all, but it did find some new obscure, sloppy websites to attack which suggests that they did not want to acknowledge that any of their critics pointed out they knew they deliberately highlighted hoaxes to avoid the real evidence.
Hearst august 15, 2006 maybe the life of the nation is at stake, and maybe it isnt. The essay recounts pms experiences with the socalled 911 truth movement and analyzes some of the inaccuracies and distortions commonly found in conspiracy literature. There are nine international editions, including a nowdefunct latin american version that had been published for decades, and a newer south african edition. This insightful 192page book includes the following five chapters. Mar 01, 2007 there is terrible book debunking 911 myths out there, released by popular mechanics. Part of the editorial team that produced debunking 911 myths. Popular mechanics inspires, instructs and influences readers to help them master the modern world. The hearstowned popular mechanics targeted the 911 truth movement without ever acknowledging it by that name with a cover story in its march 2005 edition. Aug 17, 2012 my newest work, titled debunking the real 911 myths.
Aug 01, 2017 both of those factors have been cited by investigators as possibly contributing to the collapse. Hufschmids book includes a number of tangible claims regarding 911. Popular mechanics set out to investigate conspiracy theories about the 911 attacks in late 2004, just as those claims were emerging from the swamps of extremist websites and radical islamist organizations. Jun 08, 2007 long story short, per the popular mechanics debunking 911 myths book, part of the wings were likely sheared off when the plane hit the very thick walls of the pentagon. Debunking 911 myths is an excellent brief book that debunks 911 conspiracy theories with the use of sound investigative practices. Aug 26, 2006 az radio host deconstructs popular mechanics 911 disinfo researcher here perhaps is the nightmare that they dread. In the last decade popular mechanics has inserted itself in the 911 debate as the establishments alleged voice of reason, putting out a book in 2006 and then again in 2011 that uses selective citations, glaring misrepresentations, and incorrect facts to place a smoke screen of fake legitimacy over the governments official story. Among other myths, the book debunks claims related to the twin 110story towers melted steel, freefall times, puffs of dust and nanothermite. Popular mechanics became involved in investigating 911 conspiracy theories in the fall of 2004, after an advertisement ran in the new york times for the book painful questions by eric hufschmid, demanding that the 911 investigation be reopened. Windsor, it has been owned since 1958 by the hearst corporation.
Sep, 2016 in march 2005 popular mechanics, a wellknown engineering magazine, published the article debunking 911 lies. Az radio host deconstructs popular mechanics 911 disinfo. Popular mechanics responds the afterword to our book, debunking 911 myths, by pm editorinchief jim meigs, is now available online. This is part 9 of an extensive report by 911 researcher adam taylor that exposes the fallacies and flaws in the arguments made by the editors of popular mechanics pm in the latest edition of debunking 911 myths. We had no idea how much trouble we were about to stir up. Sep 07, 2011 the popular mechanics article notes that only one norad interception of a civilian airplane over north america had occurred in the decade before 911, of golfer payne stewarts learjet, and that. The result is a triumph of hard fact over conspiratorial fantasy. Book that supposedly debunks so called myths about 911. September 11, 2001 five years after the attacks many people are asking questions about what happened on that day in new york, washington and pennsylvania. Popular mechanics recently came out with an issue in which the main story was called 911. Popular mechanics, dunbar, david, reagan, brad, meigs, james b.
An answer to popular mechanics and other defenders of the official conspiracy theory resistance griffin, david ray on. Popular mechanics 2006 book debunking 911 myths did not mention at all, but it did find some new obscure, sloppy websites to attack which suggests that they did not want to acknowledge that any of their critics pointed out they knew they deliberately. Meigs, and editors of the popular mechanics book, debunking 911 myths, brad reagan and david dunbar. Sep 16, 2006 the most popular of these is a documentary called loose change. Popular mechanics began researching the facts behind 911 conspiracy theories in late 2004 and published a cover story on the topic in march 2005. Popular mechanics special report debunking 911 myths first appeared in our march 2005 issue, and was subsequently made into a book. The 911research critique of the popular mechanics article, popular mechanics attacks its 911 lies straw man, focuses on how the article avoids addressing the charges of 911 truth activists. The book adds three claims to the original list, and pads the volume with a chapter entitled the conspiracy industry which smears 911 research by falsely implying it promotes the kind of straw man claims that popular mechanics highlights and a large excerpt from nists report on the twin towers. Why conspiracy theories cant stand up to the facts. Now, in a meticulous, scientific and groundbreaking new book, popular.
The following content is from an indepth investigation of the conspiracy theories surround the attacks of 911, which was published in the march 2005 issue of popular mechanics. Top 5 911 truther myths you should be prepared to debunk. David ray griffin born august 8, 1939 is an american retired professor of philosophy of religion and theology and a 911 conspiracy theorist. However, popular mechanics pm has been the primary cheerleader in the mainstream media in defense of the nist reports ever since its book, debunking 911 myths.
Why conspiracy theories cant stand up to the facts popular mechanics, dunbar, david, reagan, brad, mccain, john on. Pm examines the evidence and consults the experts to refute the most persistent conspiracy theories of september 11. Popular mechanics is a classic magazine of popular technology. This letter invitation was hard copy mailed to popular mechanics editorinchief james b. Feb 03, 2005 the following content is from an indepth investigation of the conspiracy theories surround the attacks of 911, which was published in the march 2005 issue of popular mechanics. I read the popular mechanics book first and found it to be very lacking in substance. Popular mechanics 911 myths debunker cancels radio debate.
By virtue of his previous four books on the subject, david ray griffin is widely recognized as one of the leading spokespersons of the 911 truth movement, which. The hearstowned popular mechanics pm targeted the 911 truth movement without ever acknowledging it by that name with a cover story in its march 2005 edition. An answer to popular mechanics and other defenders of the official conspiracy theory. He digs up centuryold controversies and finds tenuous links between the magazines staff and various government officials. Meigs, analyzing the nature of conspiracies theories related to september 11. Meigs was recently on fox news, oreilly factor touting the popular mechanics book as the final answer on 911. The persistence of the fringe movement that blames the u. The impact of the hijacked flights into the twin towers caused immense damage within the buildings. Popular mechanics provides readers with a useful reference that addresses the most common conspiracy theory claims. This book, written by eminent scholars, explains clearly what every responsible citizen should know about 911.
Why conspiracy theories cant stand up to the facts, was published in 2006. Why conspiracy theories cant stand up to the facts is a nonfiction book published by hearst communications, inc. Now, in a meticulous, scientific and groundbreaking new book, popular mechanics puts these rumors to rest. The magazines editors analyze the 20 most persistent claims underlying 911 conspiracy theoriesand conclusively disprove each one. On september 11, 2006, dylan avery and jason bermas appeared on democracy now. An answer to popular mechanics and other defenders of the official conspiracy theory by. Maybe this is a time of unprecedented tyranny, and maybe it is simply what was just out of view on the same road we have been traveling for the last seventy years. The bogus 911 websites page has long debunked about half the 16 claims that pm dishonestly identifies with 911 truth. Special report the following content is from an indepth investigation of the conspiracy theories surround the attacks of 911, which was published in the march 2005 issue of popular mechanics.
Pulling the strings is the grand dame of hearst magazines and behind the scene is her obscure husband a veteran propaganda expert and former special assistant to the director of the c. Mar 07, 2018 911 conspiracy theories are the belief that 911 was an inside job by government officials as an agenda to have an excuse to attack afghanistan and iraq. That cover story was expanded and published in august 2006 as a book titled debunking 911 myths. Score one for popular mechanics debunking 911 myths 2011. Why popular mechanics cant face up to reality, is a pointbypoint refutation of popular mechanics weak arguments regarding the controlled demolition of the three wtc buildings. The conspiracy theory consists of mainly two theories, but there are a lot of motives that many 911 theorists believe in. How believers in the 911 conspiracy theory respond to. The campaign posited that the world trade center was brought down in a controlled demolition and that the pentagon was never hit by a jetliner. This article, by way of rebuttal of the deceptive strawman tactics of popular mechanics, examines the evidence for and against the official story which is itself a conspiracy theory of the 911 attacks on the world trade center and the pentagon, and concludes that there is no evidence to support the official story, and in fact that it cannot be true.
Proving the 911 conspiracists wrong by john hawkins. Popular mechanics lied to the american people about 911. The response to that piece was so overwhelming the editors decided to continue the project and to publish a book length version of our results. Popular mechanics inspires, instructs and influences readers to help them master the modern world, whether its practical diy homeimprovement tips, gadgets and digital technology, information on. Popular mechanics examines the evidence and consults the experts to refute the most persistent conspiracy theories of september 11. In august 2006, popular mechanics published a book, debunking 911 myths why conspiracy theories cant stand up to the facts, in which a number of. Upon examination it turns out to be a shoddy piece of disinfo produced in a desperate attempt to defend against the fact that americans are finally waking up. The authors interviewed over 300 sources for the book, relying on expert and witness accounts. Popular mechanics official 911 debunking prison planet. Why conspiracy theories cant stand up to the facts by popular mechanics debunking 911 myths is an excellent brief book that debunks 911 conspiracy theories with the use of sound investigative practices. Reid, daily mail 911 conspiracy theories are and remain an extraordinary belief because if the evidence to support the conspiracies is true it.
Now, a book dealing with many of these theories has just been published by the magazine popular mechanics, its called debunking 911 myths. An excerpt from the new book based on popular mechanics march 2005 cover story. The conspiracy to rewrite 911 conspiracy theorists. It is the fourth part of this work which is the most crucial for those opposed to the official theory, for it involves countering the most widely publicized 911 debunking account. Oct, 2006 afterword to popular mechanics magazines book, debunking 911 myths, by editorinchief james b. Soon after, the title of the articles online edition was changed to the slightly less aggressivesounding debunking 911 myths. If you thought popular mechanics updated 2011 book refuted the socalled conspiracy theories about 911. Special report the world trade center and other alleged debunking in his book, debunking 911 debunking. I understand you will be airing an debate between a spokesperson for the popular mechanics book debunking 911 myths, and dylan avery, the mid20s maker of loose change a film that been used to discredit the 911 truth movement repeatedly because of its uncritical promotion of easily debunked theories, such as plane. May 01, 2007 a friend of mine is a 911 conspiracy guy so i thought that i would check this book out. This effort by david ray griffin, is a direct answer to the arguments presented in aforementioned book.
484 559 273 888 891 1390 1352 1375 818 1313 1504 1083 1627 1381 1108 1139 483 989 495 759 1673 1702 386